Rufino Cardinal Santos Steers the Archdiocese of Manila to Vatican II (1959-1966)*
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.57106/scientia.v13i1.167Keywords:
Church history, Archbishops of Manila, Vatican II, Challenge and response, PhilippinesAbstract
Rufino J. Santos was labeled as a conservative who resisted change, especially during the last half of his stewardship as archbishop of the Archdiocese of Manila. In an era when the Catholic world was beset by the liturgical revival movement and other social movements of the 1960s, Santos strived to preserve his role as a Church militant while the Philippine ecclesiastical hierarchy veered towards making the Catholic Church responsive to the contemporary social ills. The present study uses the historical method framed by Arnold Toynbee’s Challenge and Response theory to discuss, narrate, and analyze how the first Filipino Cardinal preserved the unity and tradition of pre-Vatican II ideals while ironically, being an active participant in the four Vatican II Council Sessions. This study contextualizes how Santos’ adherence to unity and uniformity was driven by his intent to avoid confusion among the priests and the laity and how this intent steered him to spearhead the introduction of the Misa ng Bayan, the first Tagalog translation of the Holy Mass in 1966, as he defied his critics, and ultimately brought the Philippines into the threshold of change that Vatican II envisioned.
Downloads
References
Newspaper Articles
“’Dialogues’ Urged to be held in Parishes,” Filipinas, 7 May 1966: 1.
“A Filipino Cardinal,” Manila Chronicle, 4 March 1960: 4.
“Abbey church implements recent liturgical changes,” The Bedan, 20 April 1965: 4.
“Abbey initiates concelebration,” The Bedan, 13 September 1965: 8.
Alberto, Estanislao. “Santos Named 1st Filipino Cardinal,” Manila Chronicle, 4 March 1960, 2.
“An Easter Message,” Filipinas, 21 April 1962: 1.
Bantigue, Pedro. “Ringing of Church Bells,” Filipinas, 6 October 1962: 2.
“Bishop Express Views,” Filipinas, 17 November 1962: 1. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/40198654
Bracker, Milton. “Showdown at Hand in Council on Bishops’ Roles.” The New York Times, 11 November 1963: 15.
Buhain, Teddy. “The Philippine Hierarchy at the Council Opening,” Filipinas, 27 October 1962: 2.
Calderon, Aurelio B. “Voices in the Woods,” The Sentinel, 12 March 1960: 2.
“Cardinal Calls for Church-State Unity,” Sentinel, 30 April 1960: 3.
“Cardinal Calls for Renewal, Speaks on ‘Family Planning,” Filipinas, 5 March 1966: 6.
“Cardinal Cautions Clergy, Laity Vs. Liturgy Novelties,” Filipinas, 7 January 1967: 1.
“Cardinal Cites Responsibility of PI Catholics,” Manila Bulletin, 9 April 1960: 1.
“Cardinal Issues First Statement,” The Manila Times, 4 March 1960: 1.
“Cardinal Leaves for Rome Sept 14,” Filipinas, 8 September 1962: 1.
“Cardinal Off to Rome; Voting Machines Planned,” Filipinas, 5 May 1962: 1.
“Cardinal Santos airs message to PI,” Manila Chronicle, 30 March 1960: 10.
“Cardinal Santos Gets Key Vatican Posts,” Sentinel, 23 April 1960: 1.
“Cardinal Santos Urges Vernacular in Gospel,” The Sentinel, 17 October 1965: 9.
“Cardinal to Say Mass at Araneta Coliseum,” Sentinel, 16 April 1960: 1.
“Cardinal-Elect, Party Depart for Vatican,” Sentinel, 19 March 1960: 1 and 16.
“Changes in the Liturgy in our Time,” Sentinel, 6 September 1964: 5.
“Congress Hails New Cardinal,” The Manila Times, 5 March 1960: 1 and 2.
“CWO Releases Texts of New Decrees on Liturgy,” Sentinel, 17 May 1964: 2.
Dinglasan, Martin. “Letter to the Editor,” Sentinel, 26 July 1964: 2.
Editor. “We’re not behind in Liturgical Reform,” Sentinel, 26 July 1964: 2.
“First Mass in Pilipino to Be Sung by Choir,” Sentinel, 1 November 1964: 7.
“First Session Ends Dec 8 Changes in Mass, Sacraments Eyed,” Filipinas, 17 November 1962: 1.
“Garcia, Veep hail elevation,” The Manila Times, 4 March 1960: 1.
GVO. “We’re Seeing Red—The Hat, We Mean,” The Sentinel, 13 December 1958: 4.
“How idea of Convoking the Council Came about,” Filipinas, 26 May 1962: 1.
“How to Stop Worrying and Love the Liturgical Change,” The Bedan, 18 February 1965: 1.
“Joyful Throng Hails Cardinal,” Manila Times, 9 April 1960: 1.
Katigbak, Maria K. “Red Carpet Awaits Cardinal,” Sentinel, 9 April 1960: 1.
“Liturgy Decrees Out,” The Sentinel, 12.
“Local Liturgical Movement Hailed,” Filipinas, 19 May 1962: 1.
Lopez, Justo N. “Liturgy and the Laity,” Filipinas, 30 June 1962: 5.
“More on Liturgy and Editor’s Note,” Sentinel, 30 August 1964: 2.
“More on Liturgy, Movies, Sacristans,” Sentinel, 9 August 1964: 2.
“Mourning Period Set for Prelate,” Manila Chronicle, 1.
“Msgr. Santos Named First P.I. Cardinal,” Manila Bulletin, 1 and 11.
“Msgr. Santos Named First P.I. Cardinal; Garcia Hails Event,” Manila Bulletin, 4 March 1960: 1.
“Nation hails appointment of PI Cardinal,” Manila Chronicle, 5 March 1960: 1.
“New Cardinals Approach Throne At St. Peters,” Sentinel, 9 April 1960: 8.
“New Officials Chosen for Catholic Welfare Organization,” Sentinel, 9 February 1964: 2.
“New Vital Commission Established,” The Sentinel, 13 February 1966: 12.
“Ordinary of Mass in Tagalog, OK’d,” Filipinas, 17 December 1966: 1.
[PHOTO] Rufino Card. Santos to Secretary Jose E. Romero re: collection of campaigns for the Rizal Shrine, Sentinel, 11 June 1960: 6.
[PHOTO] Secretary Jose E. Romero to Card. Santos re: collection of campaigns for the Rizal Shrine, Sentinel, 11 June 1960: 7.
[PHOTO], Manila Times, 9 April 1960: 1.
[PHOTO], Sentinel, 30 April 1960: 1.
“P.I. Acclaims Cardinal,” The Sentinel, 12 March 1960: 1.
“P.I. Jubilant Over Cardinal,” Manila Bulletin, 5 March 1960: 13.
“Parishes to Conduct ‘Dialogues,” Filipinas, 23 July 1966: 1 and 6.
“Programs for Dialogues’ Group Meetings,” Filipinas, 23 April 1966: 5.
“San Beda Abbey girds for March 7 Lit. changes,” The Bedan, 18 February 1965: 1.
Santos, Rufino J. “Invitation,” Filipinas, 23 April 1966: 1.
“Santos is Cardinal,” The Manila Times, 4 March 1960: 1 and 10.
“Santos Vows PI Loyalty to Pope,” The Manila Times, 29 March 1960: 8.
“Sketches of Six of the Cardinal-Designates,” The New York Times, 4 March 1960: 3.
“The Council is in Session,” Filipinas, 24 November 1962: 1.
“The New Mass,” The Sentinel, 28 February 1965, 2.
Vandromme, Leo. “Changes in the Liturgy in our Time,” Sentinel, 6 September 1964: 5 and 7.
“Visayan Prelates Urge Vernacular in Liturgy,” Sentinel, 20 September 1964: 5.
“We’re Behind in Liturgy, Counters Letter Writer,” Sentinel, 16 August 1964: 2.
Ymzon, Cesar. “The Dialogue Mass,” Filipinas, 17 November 1962: 6.
Periodicals
“Consistorium Publicum.” Acta Apostolicae Sedis 52, No. 5 (7 May 1960), 332-334.
Ioannis Pp. Xxiii, “Sollemnis Allocutio Ad Emos Patres Cardinales In Urbe Praesentes Habita, Die Xxv Ianuarii Anno Mcmlix, In Coenobio Monachorum Benedictinorum Ad S. Pauli Extra Moenia, Post Missarum Sollemnia, Quibus Beatissimus Pater In Patriarchali Basilica Ostiensi Interfuerat.” Acta Apostolicae Sedis 51 no. 2 (January 1959), 65-69.
John XXIII, “Pope sets Opening of Ecumenical Council.” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 36, no. 405 (April 1962), 221-222.
Laurentin, René. “Vatican II: Report on the First Session.” CrossCurrents 13, no. 4 (1963): 401–76. http://www.jstor.org/stable/24457226.
Lercaro, Giacomo. “Consilium ad exsequendam Constitutionem de Sacra Liturgia Insularum Philippinarum” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 39, no. 436 (March 1965), 373.
Maramba, Dom Benildus Ma. “The Pilipino Chant.” The Spires 6 no. 43 (1964), 45-56.
“Preparations for the Council.” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 36, no. 410 (October 1962), 628-629.
Rosales, Julio R. “Bishops Pastoral Letter on the Ecumenical Council.” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 36, no. 404 (March 1962), 164-167.
Rosales, Julio R. “Decree of The Philippine Hierarchy on the Use of Vernacular in the Liturgy.” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 40, no. 447 (March 1966), 190-194.
Rosales, Julio R. “On Liturgical Revival.” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 35, no. 398 (September 1961), 530-534.
Santos, Rufino. “Circular Letter Re: Intensive Spiritual Preparation for the Ecumenical Council 31 May 1961.” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 35, no. 396 (July 1961), 392-393.
Segreteria Di Stato, “Diarium Romanae Curiae.” Acta Apostolicae Sedis 52 no. 5 (7 May 1960), 364-368.
The Benedictine Fathers, “The Filipino Chant.” The Spires 6 no. 43 (1964), 58-72.
“The Sacred College of Cardinals.” The Catholic World in Pictures, May 30, 1960: 1-2, https://jstor.org/stable/community.32151726.
Vatican Press Office, “Report from the Ecumenical Council.” Boletin Eclesiastico de Filipinas 37, no. 413 (January 1963), 33-41.
Journal Articles
Chupungco, Anscar J. “The Liturgical Reform of Vatican II: The Philippine Experience” Asian Perspectives in the Arts and Humanities 1, no. 2 (2011), 79-93. DOI: https://doi.org/10.13185/AP2011.01205
Kroeger, James H. “Philippine Participation in the Second Vatican Ecumenical Council”, Philippiniana Sacra 42, no. 124 (January-April 2007),” 173-182. DOI: https://doi.org/10.55997/ps1008xlii124a8
Books
Benedict XV, The 1917 or Pio-Benedictine Code of Canon Law: in English translation with extensive scholarly apparatus, trans. Dr. Edward N. Peters, San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2001.
Congar, Yves. My Journal of the Council, trans. Mary John Ronayne and Mary Cecily Boulding. Adelaide: ATF Theology, 2012.
Daley, Brian E. “Mary in the Ressourcement and at Vatican II,” in Mary on the Eve of the Second Vatican Council, ed. John C. Cavadini and Danielle M. Peters. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 2017.
Lopez, Justo N. The Creation of the First Filipino Cardinal. Manila: no publisher indicated, 1960.
Nainfa, John Abel. Costume of Prelates of the Catholic Church according to Roman Etiquette. France: John Murphy Company, 1926.
National Catholic Welfare Conference. Council Daybook: Vatican II, Session 1 (Oct. 11 to Dec. 8, 1962) and Session 2 (Sept. 29 to Dec. 4, 1963). Washington: National Catholic Welfare Conference, Inc., 2008.
Rynne, Xavier. Letters from the Vatican City Vatican Council II (First Session): Background and Debates. New York: Farrar, Strauss & Company, 1963.
Rynne, Xavier. The Second Session. New York: Farrar, Strauss & Company, 1964.
Santos, Rufino J. Circular Letter on Liturgical Renovation. Pasay City: Daughters of Saint Paul, 1965.
Wicks, Jared. Investigating Vatican II: Its Theologians, Ecumenical Turn, and Biblical Commitment. Washington: The Catholic University of America Press, 2018. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt21pxmv0
Wittgen, Ralph M. The Rhine Flows into The Tiber A History of Vatican II. Illinois: Tan Books and Publishers, Inc, 1978.
Directory
Catholic Directory of the Philippines 1959, (Manila: Catholic Trade School, 1959)
Electronic Sources
John XXIII. “Address of the Holy Father John XXIII to the Sacred College on the Occasion of the Consistory” Monday, March 28, 1960.” The Holy See. Accessed February 9, 2023. https://www.vatican.va/content/john-xxiii/es/speeches/1960/documents/hf_j-xxiii_spe_19600328_concistoro.html.
John XXIII. “Address of the Holy Father John XXIII on the Occasion of the Imposition of the Cardinal Beretta.” The Holy See. Accessed February 9, 2023. https://www.vatican.va/content/john-xxiii/it/speeches/1960/documents/hf_j-xxiii_spe_19600330_berretta.html.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Melanie Magpantay, Antonio Hila
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
